This preliminary program is subject to change.

System Analysis – Methods to Evaluate and Compare the Economics of Ccus Technologies


Description:
The objective of this session is to describe various methodologies used to evaluate the cost and performance of carbon capture, utilization and sequestration (CCUS) technologies and discuss how they might be standardized to permit more meaningful comparisons among different studies. Major topics include design basis specifications, definition of cost and performance metrics, and techniques for assessing economic feasibility. Questions that may be addressed include: - What aspects of a design basis could be standardized for CCUS studies: ambient conditions, fuel specifications, capacity factors, finance structures, carbon dioxide purity, emergency venting, storage/utilization specifications, etc.? How might a standard design basis be complicated by environmental regulations that vary internationally? - Commonly used terms and metrics are frequently defined differently across studies, e.g., capital costs, operating and maintenance costs, cost of electricity, cost of capturing/avoiding CO2. Can definitions for these terms be standardized? - What are the most frequently used methods to calculate metrics that measure economic performance, such as cost of electricity and cost of avoiding carbon dioxide emissions? How do techniques differ between retrofit applications and greenfield plants? How should carbon dioxide utilization opportunities be factored into economic evaluations, e.g., selling carbon dioxide for enhanced oil recovery? - What techniques should be used when assessing conceptual or non-commercial technologies? How should process contingencies and learning curves be applied? How should developmental cost targets, first-of-a-kind costs, and nth-of-a-kind costs be related and compared

Sponsor:
Gas Separation
Co-Sponsor(s):
Carbon Sequestration - Geologic (TDC), ICE2012: Fossil Fuels & CCS (T4G)


Co-chairs:
Mark Woods
Booz Allen Hamilton
NETL
Pittsburgh, PA Email: mark.woods@CONTR.netl.doe.gov

John Wimer
Department of Energy, National Energy Technology Laboratory
Morgantown, WV Email: john.wimer@netl.doe.gov


Papers:
Proposed Baselines and Standard Methods for Systems Analyses of Power Generation Technologies
Michael Matuszewski, Performance Division - Office of Program Planning & Analysis, National Energy Technology Laboratory
Methodology for Evaluating the Cost of Emerging CCS Technologies
Abhoyjit S. Bhown, Electric Power Research Institute; George Booras, Electric Power Research Institute; Ronald Schoff, Electric Power Research Institute
NETL CO2 Injection and Storage Cost Model
Tim Grant, DOE/National Energy Technology Laboratory; Dave Morgan, DOE/National Energy Technology Laboratory; Jason Valenstein, Booz Allen Hamilton, Inc., USA; Andrea Poe, Booz Allen Hamilton, Inc., USA; Marta Milan, Booz Allen Hamilton, Inc., USA; Richard Lawrence, Advanced Resources International, Inc., USA
A Monte Carlo Approach for Estimating and Validating Contingencies for CCS
Paul Worhach, Nexant, Inc.; Mark Woods, Booze Allen; John Wimer, Department of Energy, National Energy Technology Laboratory