The Challenges of Commissioning Memorials: Symbolic Actions, Political Pressures and Visual Literacy

Affiliated Society or Committee Name: Public Art Dialogue
Since the events of Charlottesville, memorials have been a primary focus of local and national news, and public art historians have increasingly been called upon to serve on civic memorial commissions and selection panels. Based upon our experiences in New York and Boston, we have become increasingly aware of the problematics of practices that are often driven by symbolic actions, political pressures and visual literacy—or the lack thereof. Despite their significance memorials do not actually ameliorate the sociopolitical issues prompting the controversies that surround them, though these controversies can dramatically increase opportunities for civic engagement and advance social justice issues. Political pressures may stem from those in official positions of power as well as local individuals and community and special interest groups directly affected by or strongly supportive of these issues. Although visual literacy is crucial to interpreting visual forms in coherent ways or considering their impact on the public spaces in which they will be sited, such literacy is often in short supply among memorial selection committee members. Best practices are sorely needed in this ongoing enterprise, which shows no sign of abating in the current political climate; hopefully this panel may help jump-start their formation.

Field of Study:
Twenty-First Century
Twentieth Century
Modern (1800-present)
Interdisciplinary
Intermedia

Chairs:
Harriet F. Senie,City College of New York, CUNY - hfsenie@gmail.com and Cher Krause Knight,Emerson College - cher_knight@emerson.edu

Facing Not Erasing: Confederate Monuments as Healing Tools of American Collective Trauma
Erika Lindsay, University of Detroit Mercy School of Architecture
Inclusion and Exclusion: A Critical Analysis of Public Monuments at Canada’s Pier 21
Patience Adamu, Ryerson University; Wendy Cukier, Ryerson University
Accidental Counter-Monument: A Postmortem on Sam Durant’s Scaffold
Shannon Hebert Waldman, The School of the Art Institute of Chicago