Myths of the “Medieval” in Modern American Historiography

AHA Session 150
Friday, January 5, 2024: 3:30 PM-5:00 PM
Market Street (Parc 55, Third)
Chair:
Courtney Luckhardt, University of Southern Mississippi
Comment:
The Audience

Session Abstract

In his 1981 book No Place of Grace, T. J. Jackson Lears outlined the central role of the “medieval” in the imagination of modern bourgeois intellectuals in the late-nineteenth and early-twentieth century. American scholars and ideologues have long deployed ideas of the Middle Ages to justify contemporary political projects. Whereas scholars outside of History have identified the use of “the medieval” in contemporary discourses of racism and difference, historians have been less critical of our discipline’s use of these ideas.

To begin to remedy this shortcoming, the papers presented in this panel will continue Lears’s project by interrogating how Americans have used “the medieval” to confront the uncertainties of their modern moment. The topics of our panel range explore the contested production of medieval history, from roughly the Gilded Age to WWII. They identify the different ways the distant past has been theorized and crafted for modern purposes and audiences and the stakes of those discussions.

Understanding how the medieval past has been used politically in the past helps us to understand how it is being used for political ends in the present. This panel is a unique opportunity to bring historians of the Middle Ages and Modern America together to share our unique skill sets to grapple with the purpose and significance of historical study.

See more of: AHA Sessions