Re-thinking Indigenized Religious Painting: Retablos, Sanctuarios and Ex-Votos in 18th 19th-Century Mexico

Session will present: In-Person

Since its inception in New Spain, the precarious role of indigenized artists in European painting practice was contingent on new laws, which constrained their participation in the guild system. Indigenous creativity, as noted by historian Serge Gruzinski, was only recognized, “if it knew how to stay invisible,” effectively obscuring these considerable contributions from art history’s canon. Work deemed “popular” dominated the late eighteenth- and nineteenth-century unofficial painting market. One significant contribution is the syncretic manifestations of religious iconography that continues to dominate today’s so-called religious folk art market such as ex-votos and retablos.

“Popular religious painting” has been examined by scholars primarily for its documentary value, disregarding the aesthetic, ethnographic, and religious value it presents for the study of Novohispanic and Mexican history. The theoretical position of indigenized art as neither fine art nor historic(al) document arrests it to a fixed place as “curious” and “naive” expressions of the past. This panel will re-consider the nomenclature and academic positionality surrounding “popular religious painting,” by recentering the study, collecting, display, and making of ex-votos within the context of the spiritual and creative life of indigeneized communities. We posit that, in ways both unlike and similar to their academic counterparts, these paintings conveyed historical and spiritual narratives, demonstrated popular religious practices, depicted surrounding environments and objects, all while offering a means of healing, closure, and spiritual expansion for those who doubted the power of faith.


Field(s) of Study:
Geographic Area: Mexico
Time Period: Modern (1800-present)
Media: Painting
Topics: Religion
Theory / Practice: Material Culture

Chair:
Emmanuel Ortega, University of Illinois Chicago

Discussant:
Rick Lopez, Amherst College

“Super-Artifacts: Displacing Ex-votos from the Traps of Art History”
Emmanuel Ortega, University of Illinois Chicago
Abstract Submissions Closed