Guilty Pleasures: Art History and Other Clichés

Session will present: Virtually

Leo Steinberg famously asserted that the critic is “the generator of the cliché.” Repellent yet inevitable, clichés are deeply embedded in art history. Under the conditions of neoliberal cultural production, even the most transgressive intervention––theoretical, historical, or artistic––is caught up in a cycle of reproduction and assimilation until it transforms into a consumable commodity that eventually falls out of fashion. From Warhol’s Americana iconographies to projections of Impressionist art in immersive environments, clichés loom large in the precincts of art and consumer culture.

One type of cliché is the guilty pleasure: the art we love to hate. The guilty pleasure is a relatively new category of experience, a complex knot of shame about consumerism and the enjoyment of consumption. Guilty pleasures typically refer to reality television, pop music, and comfort food, but they haven’t been seriously considered in the realm of art history.

This panel approaches guilty pleasures and clichés on methodological and representational levels; we welcome papers that interrogate these terms as productive categories of cultural inquiry as they intersect with art history, criticism, or visual culture. Papers might address: To what extent do clichés overlap with trash imagery, camp aesthetics, and spectacular gimmicks? Can these phenomena subvert art history’s pretense of detachment and elitism? How does acknowledging guilty pleasures signify a return to an affective encounter with art? While the guilty pleasure has been codified as a cultural condition of late twentieth-century America, presenters may engage with the concept as it emerges in any region or period.


Field(s) of Study:
Theory / Practice: Art Criticism
Topics: Visual Culture
Theory / Practice: Methodologies
Theory / Practice: Theory
Media: Interdisciplinary


Chairs:
Linden Hill, Stanford University and Ron Elizedek Reichman, Stanford University

The Guilty Pleasures of Paint
Ian Rothwell, Edinburgh College of Art
Abstract Submissions Closed